r/pianolearning - a piano in a room

Image sourced from Reddit

Do you get confused when choosing between Adjustable and fixed piano benches? While choosing the right piano receives a lot of attention, comfort, and technique are greatly influenced by the bench. 

The two primary varieties of options are piano benches that are movable and those that are fixed, and each has unique benefits and drawbacks.

In order to assist you in selecting the kind that best meets your needs, this article explores the qualities of both types of piano keyboard benches. 

Importance of the Right Piano Bench

Just before you choose an option between fixed and adjustable benches, it's critical to know and understand that why selecting the right bench that accommodates your needs is crucial:

  • Posture

  • Sitting correctly guarantees that your posture is suitable for playing, which helps to avoid straining your neck and back.

  • Technique

  • Your hand and arm motions, which are essential for proper technique, are influenced by the bench's height and stability.

  • Comfort

  •  A comfortable bench can help you focus better and reduce fatigue during extended practice sessions.

    Adjustable Piano Benches

  • Features and Advantages

  • The purpose of adjustable piano benches is to enable the user to change the seating surface's height. Usually, they have a mechanism (hydraulic or manual) that allows for simple adjustment, free of any complications. 

  • Customization

  •  The capacity to adjust the height to suit specific requirements is the main benefit. This is especially helpful for families that have several pianists of all sizes and ages.

  • Ergonomics

  •  The ideal ergonomic positioning is made possible by adjusting the bench height, which lowers the danger of repetitive strain injuries.

  • Versatility

  • These benches are a flexible option for artists who may switch between instruments because they may be utilized with a variety of pianos and keyboards. 

  • Drawbacks

  • Adjustable benches have advantages, but they also have some drawbacks that can not be ignored while you are making your decision.

  • Cost

  • Because of their intricate systems, adjustable benches are typically more expensive.

  • Maintenance

  • Over time, the adjustment mechanism may wear out and need to be replaced.

  • Weight

  • When compared with the fixed ones, the benches are a lot heavier. This feature makes them less ideal for the users who are more likely to travel and carry it along themselves. 

  • Popular Types of Adjustable Bench Available

  • Here are a few notable types of adjustable benches available in the market. 

  • Hydraulic Adjustable Benches

  • These benches may be raised or lowered with ease and smoothness thanks to a hydraulic system. Although they are usually more costly, they provide better convenience.

  • Manual Screw-type Benches

  • To change the height of these, one must manually turn the knobs or levers. Compared to hydraulic solutions, they are less convenient but more reasonably priced.

    Here is a detailed video of the type of adjustable piano benches 


  • Features and Advantages of Fixed Piano Benches

  • The purpose of fixed piano keyboard benches is to give users a safe and secure place to play. These benches are made especially to accommodate a certain model of keyboard or piano, so they fit easily and comfortably. 

  • Stability

  •  Because fixed benches don't have any moving parts, they are typically more stable.

    Durability: These benches often last longer and require less maintenance because they have fewer parts that can break.

  • Cost-Effective

  • For beginners or those on a limited budget, they are a popular option because they are usually less expensive than adjustable benches.

  • Aesthetic Appeal

  • Matching designs for the piano are common on fixed benches, which improves the arrangement of the instruments visually.

  • Drawbacks

  • However, there are drawbacks to fixed benches as well. Let’s have a look at them:

  • Lack of Customisation

  • If more than one player uses the bench, the inability to change the height of these benches can be a big disadvantage.

  • Comfort Concerns

  • It can be difficult to find the ideal ergonomic posture when there is no height adjustment, which could make prolonged gaming sessions uncomfortable.

  • Less Versatile

  •  Fixed benches are designed to fit particular pianos and might not be compatible with digital pianos or other kinds of keyboards.

  • Popular Fixed Bench Types

  • You might be wondering what are the popular options available categorized under the fixed piano benches. Here are a few of them:

  • Standard Fixed Benches

  • The most popular kind of fixed benches are the standard ones, which have a constant height and a straightforward design.

  • Duet Benches

  • Wider benches made for two players, known as duet benches, are frequently seen in classrooms and during duet performances.

    Factors Involved in the Selection Between the Adjustable and Fixed Piano Keyboard Benches

    When choosing between fixed and adjustable benches, there are several crucial aspects to take into account. 

    Here's a closer look at these important aspects to help in your decision-making.

  • Player's Age and Height

  • A player's age and height are important considerations when deciding between fixed and adjustable benches. An adjustable bench is best if it will be used by a number of individuals with different heights and ages. 

    This kind of bench encourages proper posture and technique by enabling each user to adjust the height to their ideal setting. For example, adults and little children can establish a comfortable seated height without sacrificing their playing form. 

    An adjustable bench can help ensure that growing kids or teens play in an ergonomically suitable position by accommodating height variations over time. Even though they are strong, fixed benches might not provide the flexibility that developing young pianists require.

    This adaptability guarantees that the bench can change in tandem with the player's growth and style of play. Even though they are strong and frequently attractive, fixed benches lack this flexibility, which over time may cause pain or bad posture.

  • The Environment

  • Another important factor to take into account when choosing a piano bench is the playing environment. A lightweight fixed bench might be more useful in a home situation where the bench would need to be moved sometimes. 

    Because fixed benches are more easily movable and have a simpler design, they are a good fit for homes with flexible space and layout requirements. In a professional or studio setting, an adjustable bench's customization feature might be more advantageous. 

    Precise changes are frequently needed in professional settings to suit various players or to obtain the best playing posture during extended practice sessions. These precise adjustments are made possible by an adjustable bench, which guarantees that every pianist can provide their finest performance. 

    Furthermore, fixed benches are a suitable option in environments where the bench is placed in a permanent location due to their solidity and durability. Conversely, because they include moving elements, adjustable benches may need more upkeep and attention in these kinds of settings.

  • Budget

  • Before purchasing anything, it is important to consider the budget. Since their complicated mechanisms make adjustable benches more expensive overall, their advantages may outweigh the price, especially for dedicated musicians. 

    Investing in a top-notch adjustable bench can improve performance and comfort while possibly lowering the chance of damage from bad posture. A fixed bench could make more sense for people who are just starting or have limited resources. Fixed benches are typically less expensive and can still offer novices the comfort and support they need. 

    But it's crucial to take the bench's long-term worth into account. Long-term cost savings may result from an adjustable bench's higher initial expenditure because there would be no need to replace it when a player's needs alter. 

    On the other hand, fixed benches provide an affordable option that maintains both fundamental functioning and aesthetic appeal.

  • How Often You Use It

  • The frequency of use should be taken into account while choosing between fixed and adjustable benches. Long or frequent playing sessions require the comfort and ergonomic advantages that an adjustable bench may offer. 

    Precise height modifications are made possible by adjustable benches, which help lessen strain and fatigue during extended playing sessions. Professional pianists or dedicated learners who practice for several hours every day should pay special attention to this. A stationary bench could be enough for sporadic use.

    A fixed bench makes more sense because it's simpler and less expensive if the piano isn't played frequently. But even for seldom use, it's crucial to make sure the seat is cozy and offers enough support to uphold good posture. The choice should strike a balance between the value of comfort and ergonomics in improving the playing experience and the frequency of use.

  • Practical Considerations

  • While deciding between adjustable and fixed benches, practical factors like portability, durability, and upkeep should also be considered. Long practice meetings require an ergonomic seat that is solid and feels much more comfortable. 

    A customizable seat can be a good decision if more than one individual will use the seat. The seat should be already incredibly solid to endure successive use without giving way. Select building materials and techniques that will guarantee the bench's longevity.

    For long-lasting use, solid wood and good-quality upholstery materials are preferred. 

    List of Top Piano Benches

    Here is a list of top 6 piano benches

     

  • Brown Genuine Leather Piano Bench

  •  

     

    The Brown Genuine Leather Piano Bench is a height-adjustable bench with padded leather seating. The seat has an 11-button deep diamond pattern that makes the bench attractive.

    Specifications

    • The total length of the piano bench is 26 inches, with knobs
    • The total width of the piano bench is 15 inches
    • The piano bench has a 100 percent genuine brown leather seat top
    • The piano bench is made up of a solid wooden frame
    • The total weight capacity of the piano bench is 350 pounds
    • The total weight of the piano bench is 30 pounds
    • The piano bench has a storage area with a depth of 1.25 inches 
    • The piano bench has a height adjustability of 19 3/4 inches to 24 inches

    Pros

    • The high-quality, genuine leather seating gives an aesthetic look to the piano bench.
    • The wooden framework makes the piano bench solid, sturdy, and durable
    • The elegant design can used to complement various decors

    Cons

    • The price might be on the higher side
    • The piano bench is not specially designed for duet performance

    Here is a customer review from our client Adeboye Babalola

    Excellent quality!

    I was looking for something that was sturdy, comfortable, and height - adjustable (I prefer benches on the high side). This met all of those requirements and beyond. I received the most elegant piece of furniture that looked and smelled of fine craftsmanship. I'm not sure if i've ever opened up anything that was so pristine. The packing emanated care and assembly was straightforward (if slightly tedious). The bench has yet to stand the test of time as I just received and assembled yesterday, but i will have to report back about long-term use at another time. As far as storage goes, the compartment is tiny (ultra-thin) and it seem like a lot of extra work on the manufacturer's part for nothing. HOWEVER, I do not purchase an artist bench for storage (and don't expect it) but, instead, for it's quality level of durability and support. I'm quite optimistic that this bench will bring me years of satisfaction while I play the piano.

     

  • Black Piano Bench

  •  

    r/piano - Bench Height

       Image sourced from Reddit

    The Black Piano Bench is a 29-inch-long duet piano bench that provides enough room for two individuals to perform easily.

    Specifications

    • The length of the piano bench is 29 inches
    • The width of the piano bench is 13 
    • The height of the piano bench is 19
    • The piano bench has a padded seat
    • The total weight capacity of the piano bench is 300 pounds
    • The total weight of the piano bench is 22 pounds
    • The piano bench has a storage area

    Pros

    • The storage area in the piano bench can be used for keeping music sheets
    • The piano  bench has an elegant design that enhances its appeal
    • The piano bench comes at an affordable price 

    Cons

    • The synthetic leather is not as durable and long-lasting as the original leather.
    • The piano bench lacks the height adjustability feature.

     

  • Drum Throne Stool

  •  

    r/edrums - Any tips for setup/positioning

    Image sourced from Reddit

    The Drum Throne Stool is a drum throne with a padded drummer seat that is specially designed for the drummers but can be used as a piano bench

    Specifications

    • The drum throne has a total weight capacity of 215 pounds
    • The weight of the drum throne is 6 pounds
    • The seat is height adjustable from 19 to 23 inches
    • The base pipe has a diameter of 25mm
    • The diameter of the seat is 12 inches

    Pros

    • The height adjustability of the drum throne makes it suitable for people with different heights.
    • The drum throne has a portable design 
    • The drum throne is made up of a durable metal frame that can last longer

    Cons

    • The piano bench is not specially made for piano usage
    • There is no storage area 

     

  • Adjustable Piano Bench

  •  

    The Adjustable Piano Bench is a solid wooden frame piano bench with soft padded seats. Its frame has a black glossy finish.

    Specifications

    • The length of the piano bench is 22 inches
    • The width of the piano bench is 13 inches 
    • The height adjustability of the piano bench is 19 to 23.5 inches
    • The piano bench has a 1.5-inch deep storage area
    • The piano bench has a weight capacity of 300 pounds
    • The piano bench has its own weight of 26 pounds
    • The piano bench seat is made up of synthetic leather

    Pros

    • The height adjustability provides comfort for all users
    • The padded seat gives a soft and comfy feel 
    • The storage compartment can be used to store necessary items
    • The piano bench is made up of a sturdy frame, which makes it durable and withstands heavyweights

    Cons

    • The synthetic leather is not as reliable as genuine one
    • The prix might be a concern

    Here is what our client Shirley Abrahams has to say about the piano bench

    Superb! Couldn't be happier

    Our son just started piano for a year and we didn't want to invest in something hundreds of dollars that we may not need in the future. This is perfect, suited to his height and he no longer wobbles and can sit well and play. He just turned 6yo. We are so happy with this!! It looks and feels nice. Very sturdy, and you can even store piano books in it (tho not very big space). We got the black one, as the brown seems to be very brown from other's photos. Our piano is very dark brown and the black looks ok with it. The price is very reasonable for what it is.  

     

  • 5Core Portable Piano Keyboard Music X-Style Adjustable Padded Stool Chair Seat Bench 

  •  

    r/piano - So I just bought a p125 with a stand and a chair and it feels like the piano is too high even on the stands lowest setting , what’s up with that ? Should it be okay or should I look for a higher seat ?

    Image sourced from Reddit

    The 5 Core Portable Piano Keyboard Music X-Style Bench is a piano bench that is height adjustable and highly portable.

    Specifications

    • The piano bench has an X-style design 
    • The piano bench is made up of a metal frame
    • The piano bench has 3 level height adjustability 
    • The piano bench comes with cushion padding
    • The piano bench is foldable

    Pros

    • The height adjustability with different levels helps enhance the comfort of the users.
    • The piano bench is foldable, making it easier to transport it
    • The piano bench comes at an affordable price

    Cons

    • The piano bench is less sturdy if compared with the fixed ones
    • There is no such storage area on the piano bench

  • Piano Keyboard Bench with 400lb Weight Capacity (PNB-BLK-IRON)

  • The Piano Keyboard Bench with 400lb Weight Capacity (PNB-BLK-IRON) is a heavy-duty metal framed piano bench with a whooping weight capacity of 400 pounds.

    Specifications

    • The piano bench has an iron frame
    • The piano bench has a memory foam padded seat
    • The piano bench is waterproof
    • The piano bench has a seat padded thickness of 2.5 inches
    • The dimensions are 19 by 21 inches

    Pros

    • The piano bench has a high weight-bearing capacity of 400 pounds
    • The piano bench has comfortable seating because of the 2.5-inch memory foam padded seating
    • The iron frame is durable, making it bear weight and last longer

    Cons

    • The piano bench has a fixed height
    • There is no storage area
    • Synthetic leather does not last as long as original leather

    Here is a comparison table for the products

    Product 

    Best For Highlighting Feature Pros Cons
    Brown Genuine Leather Piano Bench Luxury and Comfort Genuine leather High-quality leather, comfortable, elegant design higher price
    Black Piano Bench Budget and Storage Storage compartment Comfortable, storage compartment, affordable, elegant Fixed height, faux leather
    Drum Throne Stool  Versatility Adjustable height Comfortable, adjustable height, compact, durable Not piano-specific, no storage
    Adjustable Piano Bench Adjustability and Storage Adjustable height, storage

    Adjustable height, comfortable, storage compartment, sturdy

    Faux leather, higher price
    5Core Portable Piano Keyboard Music X-Style Stool (Brown) Portability Foldable, adjustable height Adjustable height, foldable, comfortable, affordable Less sturdy, no storage
    Piano Keyboard Bench with 400lb Weight Capacity (PNB-BLK-IRON) High Weight Capacity High weight capacity High weight capacity, comfortable, durable, affordable Fixed height, no storage, faux leather

    Why Choose GeekStands for Piano Benches

    At Greekstand, we have piano benches made of high-quality materials that are comfortable and ergonomic. It is a design with adjustable features and a variety of options people often opt for!

    The piano benches are made up of high-quality material, including genuine leather solid wood, which makes them sturdy and luxurious at the same time.

    The piano benches have an ergonomic design that helps in the comfort of the users and the comfort is further enhanced with the presence of the cushioning and the height adjustability features.   

    We have a wide variety of options available for the users that suit your decor of the studio as well as provide you with the utmost functionality, so what are you waiting for? Go grab your piano bench today.